Sentencing & Pleading

A sentencing discount is a reduction in the otherwise appropriate sentence by a quantifiable amount due to a guilty plea. It is applied after the appropriate sentence has been determined [R v Borkowski at 32].

The discount should generally be assessed in the range of 10-25%. The primary consideration is the timing of the plea [R v Thomson & Houlton at 419].

It is at the Court’s discretion whether to impose a lesser penalty and they may not always do so. The sentence must not be unreasonably disproportionate to the nature and circumstances of the offence.

Guilty and not guilty pleas are discussed in more detail in the pleadings section.

A judge may order that an accused person who is committed for trial or sentence be committed to a correctional centre or place of security or otherwise brought before a court at a time and place specified if the accused has been granted bail [Criminal Procedure Act 1986, s109].

A Magistrate may at any time order the issue of an arrest warrant for an accused person [CPA s109].

A pre-sentence report may be obtained prior to hearing, however it is not compulsory. The report is prepared by a government agency, usually the Probation and Parole Service, which outlines the alternatives available to an offender other than imprisonment.

A court must not sentence an offender to imprisonment unless it is satisfied, having considered all possible alternatives, that no penalty other than imprisonment is appropriate [Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999, s5].

The Court will set a non-parole period, unless the term of imprisonment is under six months [CSPA s44]. The Court may decline to set a non-parole period given the nature of the offence or previous convictions [CSPA s45].

When a court imposes a sentence of imprisonment on an offender for more than one offence the court must impose a separate sentence in relation to each offence, unless imposing an aggregate sentence of imprisonment [CSPA s53].

Sentences can either be served consecutively or concurrently [CSPA s55].

Intensive Corrections Orders (ICOs) are covered in a previous section.

A court that has sentenced an offender to imprisonment for not more than 18 months may make a home detention order [CSPA s6]. An HDO cannot be made if the offender is already serving such an order and the combined period for both offences would exceed 18 months.

The making of a HDO is subject to the written consent of the persons with whom the offender would likely reside. An assessment of the offender’s suitability for a HDO would need to be undertaken. HDO suitability reports are prepared by the Probation and Parole Service [CSPA s78].

The Court may impose additional conditions on a Home Detention Order relating to employment or performing community service work [CSPA s82].

HDOs are not available for certain offences

1. Murder, attempted murder or manslaughter
2. Sexual assault
3. Sexual offences involving children
4. Armed robbery
5. Any offence involving use of a firearm
6. Assault occasioning actual bodily harm or any more serious assault
Certain domestic violence offences
7. Certain drug offences involving commercial quantities

[CSPA s76]

HDOs are not available for offenders who have previously been convicted of:

1. Murder, attempted murder or manslaughter
2. Sexual assault
3. Sexual offences involving children
4. Certain domestic violence offences
5. Or who is subject to an AVO, being an order made for the protection of the person with whom it is likely the offender would reside

[CSPA s77]

A Court may revoke an HDO if:

1. The offender fails to comply with the order;
2. The offender fails to appear before the parole board; or
3. A person with whom the offender resides withdraws consent

Once an HDO is revoked the offender must serve the rest of their sentence in full time custody. The offender can apply for a reinstatement where at least 3 months of the offender’s sentence has been served in full-time custody.

The Drug Court may direct the offender to serve a sentence of imprisonment by way of compulsory drug treatment detention, including alcohol abuse. An offender can undertake assessment for the MERIT Scheme (Magistrates Early Referral into Treatment Program). When the program is completed the Offender returns to Court for sentencing. Participants can also be referred through the Local Court. Involvement in the MERIT scheme may be a condition of bail. A defendant is not required to plead guilty before taking part in the MERIT scheme [CSPA s5A].

There are two drug court programs operating in NSW; the Western Sydney Drug Court and the Hunter Drug Court. To be eligible for a Drug Court program there is a requirement that an applicant to the Court be over 18 years of age and have no mental condition that would prohibit participation in the program. Further, the defendant must be dependant on the use of illicit drugs, be pleading guilty and highly likely to be given a prison sentence.

A court that finds a person guilty without proceeding to sentencing may adjourn proceedings for a maximum period of 12 months and grant bail in order to assess the offender’s capacity and prospects for participation in an intervention program or rehabilitation and allow the offender to participate in such a program. After allowing time for the offender to undertake the program, the Court will reconvene for sentencing [CSPA s11].

An offender needs to be referred by the court for an assessment of their suitability to participate in an intervention program [s100O].

An order may be made if the court is satisfied that it would reduce the likelihood of the person reoffending. Not all offenders will qualify for a participation in a program [CSPA s10].

If the Court suspects the offender has failed to comply with a program intervention order the court may call on the offender to appear before it. If the Court is satisfied that the Offender has failed to comply with the program they may revoke the order [CSPR s100R].

If the Court revokes an intervention order they may convict and sentence the offender for the original offence [100S].

A community service order can be made by the court directing the offender to perform community service work for a specified number of hours. The number of hours worked must not exceed 500, or the number of hours prescribed by the offence. An order cannot require participation for more than three times weekly and the time for participation in any one week cannot exceed 15 hours [CSPA s8].

A new community service order cannot be made in addition to a previous order if the sum of the hours exceeds 500 [CSPA s87].

A Court may impose additional conditions on a community service order including a fine, compensation, participation in development programs and testing for alcohol or drug use [CSPA s90].

A pre-sentence report will need to be obtained from the Probation and Parole Service if an offender is to be sentenced to a community service order. There needs to be arrangements existing in the area in which the offender resides to perform community service work [CSPA s86].

Without proceeding to conviction a Court that finds a person guilty of an offence may make an order discharging the person on condition that they enter into a good behaviour bond for a term not exceeding two years. An order may be made if the court is satisfied that it would reduce the likelihood of the person reoffending [CSPA s10].

Alternately, a Court may impose a criminal conviction and sentence the offender to a good behaviour bond for a specified term not to exceed five years [CSPA s9].

Conditions of good behaviour bonds:

1. Must contain a condition that the offender will appear before the court if called on at any time during the term of the bond
2. Must contain a condition that during the term of the bond the person will be of good behaviour
3. May contain a condition to perform community service work
4. May contain a condition to pay a fine or compensation
5. May contain a condition to participate in an intervention program, undergo counselling or submit to medical treatme

[CSPA s95]

If the Court suspects that an offender may have failed to comply with the conditions of a good behaviour bond the Court may call on the offender to appear. If the offender fails to appear the court may issue a warrant for the offender’s arrest. If the Court is satisfied that the offender has failed to comply with the conditions of the bond a court may vary the conditions of the bond or otherwise revoke it [CSPA s98].

If a court revokes a good behaviour bond they may:

1. Re-sentence the offender;
2. Convict and sentence the offender; or
3. Make an order directing that the sentence of imprisonment to which the bond relates be served by way of an intensive correction order or home detention.

[CSPA s99]

Fines can be imposed as an additional penalty to a good behaviour bond [CSPA s14].

Fines can otherwise be imposed as an additional or alternative penalty to a sentence including imprisonment for any indictable offence [CSPA s15].

One penalty unit accounts for $110 i.e. a fine of 50 penalty units will amount to $5,500 [CSPA s17].

A court that imposes a sentence of no more than 2 years may suspend the sentence and release the offender provided they enter a good behaviour bond for a period not exceeding the term of the sentence [CSPA s12].

If an offender breaches a suspended sentence order the Magistrate must revoke the order.

Without proceeding to conviction, a Court that finds a person guilty of an offence may make an order directing that the charge be dismissed [CSPA s10].

A Non-association Order prohibits an offender from associating with a specified person for a specified term [CSPA s17A].

A Place restriction order prohibits an offender from frequenting or visiting a specified place or district for a specified term. Such an order may be limited to certain times and circumstances [CSPA s17A].

Contravention of a non-association or place restriction order will result in a maximum penalty of 10 penalty units or six months imprisonment, or both [CSPA s100E].

A Local Court may vary or revoke an order, regardless of whether the order was made by the Local Court or another Court [CSPA s100G].

Orders pursuant to the Mental Health (Forensic Provisions) Act are covered in a previous section.